148 replies to this topic

[Proxus]

Province
Province
Province
Province
Swamp.

[Kount_Doom]

Bronze goes to Komarin. If it's meant to be a more skilled map, why does it suck so much?
Silver goes to Campinovka. Honestly, whenever possible I zerg rush across the field to get out the match.
And Gold goes to... Province! Its name in the replay folder is Campania, and that name fits better. It's a terrible cluster**** of flailing tanks, if you move anywhere you lose 90% of your HP or you just outright die without firing a shot, and even if you don't the game ends with a draw 60% of the time.

[cheesellama]

I don't have least favorite maps, only maps I'm not as good on as others.

[CHR157IAN_ALPHA]

PROVINCE SUKS BALZ [period]

for some serious opinion this map would only work if 50% larger or restricted to tier 1-3

[agentKmurph]

In no particular order:

1. Komarin - the set up is stupid because the team gets split in half between two caps; becomes a massive campfest and arty deathfield. this map would actualy be okay of the teams just started at the caps.

2. Province - Suicidal paths up to the ridges. No flanks, alternative routes, viable cover, or exploitable features. Moving will rend your tank apart immediately from a hail of sniper fire. Lights and mediums boned by size and layout. Just an awful campfest with zero maneuvering room.

3. Swamp - Too open, cover features are too small, BRIDGES - FUUUUUUUU! Arty deathfield and dominated invariably by the guy with the biggest gun.

4. Sand River - its like a poorly designed assault map type where the south west defends (camps) and the north east attacks and almost always the NE gets shredded by the campers. A lot of idle threats and waving guns over the top of hills too.

5. Ensk - its a mini Himmelsdorf. Himmelsdorf is already kinda mean to arty and mediums/lights. Did we need to make it smaller?


6th would be Karelia - fun in low tiers but its standoff between the heavies in the flanks on high tiers. No good for light and medium tanks. With only three paths its very boring as well. Malinovka is up there too but at least you have the hills on that one.


EDIT: Added my reasons http://forum.worldof...mile_blinky.gif

[Okeano]

Province
Komarin
Province
Komarin
Province

(How can anyone hate Steppes?)

[Preston_]

Province is my most hated.  

All the others I can actually live with.

[KarmaRaid]

5.                   Karelia
4.                   Mountain Pass
3.                   Komarin
2.                   Swamps

and the winner is:   Province

[2HOTGLOCKS]

1. Malinovka - I am in constant amazement every time I get this map.  I just can't believe they haven't retired it.  There is literally no cover from artillery, and so if you do anything other that just sit you die immediately and it is just terrible.

2. El Halluf - Very close 2nd.  It's super small, and there are no opportunities to be aggressive, and there is no adequate cover from artillery

3. Prokhorovka - Like every other shitty map, there just aren't enough places you can hide from artillery.

These are the only 3 that I mind

[Pattonf]

1. Campinovka
2. El Halluf
3. Swamp
4. Sand River
5. Province

Campinovka is by far the worst though.

[T_om]

Revised list:

1.  Komarin, Province.  Tied for 1st.

2.  Komarin, Province.  Tied for 2nd.

3.  Komarin, Province.  Tied for 3rd.

4.  Komarin, Province.  Tied for 4th.

5.  Komarin, Province.  Tied for 5th.

Those maps are pure bullshit from the word 'go'.

Tom

[3L1T3]

Pretty much any open-space map with minimal cover and obvious yet insurmountable choke points.
I should point out, however, that having a good team that communicates like one unit will win you a battle in any map.

[lostwingman]

Okeano, on Apr 14 2012 - 22:29, said:

Province
Komarin
Province
Komarin
Province

(How can anyone hate Steppes?)

I found a gapping flaw in your list. I see no Swamps in there.

[WarStore]

1- Malinovka
2 - Crapnovka
3- Campnovka
4 - Kamperovka
5 - Province

[burningsteppes]

My list goes something like this...

1) Himmelsdorf/Ensk/Ruinberg - Equal opportunity hatred here. Ping well north of 500ms at best makes steering, let alone aiming and firing, futility personified. Add to that the fact I pretty much suck at rattenkrieg anyway, means as often as not I get my tank pointed in the general direction of the enemy base, punch R twice and go make a sammich.

2) Komarin - Not much to say that hasn't been said about this one, though if I have to play it can I please get the north side WG... pretty please?

3) Redshire - I should like this map, but I just.... don't. *shrug*

4) Fisherman's Bay - This is another one that tends to give me bad ping, but at least it's usually manageable.

5) Swamp or Province - Don't really hate either one, but then again I don't really like them either.

[SHISHKABOB]

I sigh when I run into:

1. Komarin
2. Malinovka
those two most of all, the rest are nowhere near as bad those two IMO
3. El Halluf
4. Province I guess, though of course I won't have to bother with it after 7.3 hooray!


there really aren't any others. The rest of the maps I enjoy every game on them.

[HeavyTanker1337]

All camping maps ... i dont remember the names lol .

[lukeliu]

1. Malinovka
2. Malinovka
3. Malinovka
4. Malinovka
5. Malinovka

[Xervitus]

Province
Komarin
El Halluf
Swamps
many other maps I don't love but those three are the ones that make me want to cry when they load

Quote

4. Province I guess, though of course I won't have to bother with it after 7.3 hooray!

are they removing province in 7.3??

ahh nevermind just saw overlords blog - woo!

[Rhoninn]

PROVINCE
PROVINCE
PROVINCE
PROVINCE
PROVINCE

Get the picture? It's to damn small