←  Gameplay Discussion

Main page

»

Mistake! 7.3 update note (TD should no...

God_Of_Death_EX's Photo God_Of_Death_EX May 07 2012

Quote

Added vehicles, available for supertesters only: Soviet heavy tank IS-6 (tier 8) and German TD JagdTiger 8.8cm KwK 43 L/71 (tier 8).

The abbrv. KwK refers to KampfwagenKanone
Meaning Tank Gun (according to Google Translate)
And is for turreted tanks only
This is the historical gun for the Tiger II

The gun on the Premium JgT should be 8.8cm PaK 43 L/7
The abbrv. PaK refers to  Panzerbwehrkanone
Meaning Anti Tank Gun (according to Google translate)
PaKs should be mounted on TDs instead of the KwKs
This is the historical gun for the JagdPanther

Hope the DEVs can correct this
Quote

cheesellama's Photo cheesellama May 07 2012

No way! Who would've thought that just changing an abbreviation would affect the game so much! Oh wait, it doesn't.

No offense intended, but I'm just saying, even though that's a good point, does it make much of a difference?
Quote

Sabertoothpython's Photo Sabertoothpython May 07 2012

Why cant a tank destroyer have a tank gun? Fixed gun emplacments can. Ships can.

Someone please tell me
Quote

SHISHKABOB's Photo SHISHKABOB May 07 2012

View Postcheesellama, on May 07 2012 - 12:00, said:

No way! Who would've thought that just changing an abbreviation would affect the game so much! Oh wait, it doesn't.

No offense intended, but I'm just saying, even though that's a good point, does it make much of a difference?

one of the biggest selling points of the game is "get in a WW2 era tank and drive it around"

realistic looking tanks and names is a part of the allure. Anyone who knows much about German tanks and weapons will know the difference between KwK and PaK, and to them it *is* a big deal.


However, in this case, I feel like it was just a typo. As we've seen before, whoever is translating these things from Russians is probably often in a hurry and sometimes makes mistakes, like we all do.
Quote

KrasnayaZvezda's Photo KrasnayaZvezda May 07 2012

No offense, but it was discussed few times previously, and its name would be changed after the release as it seems that WG is well aware of it.
Quote

Tanker579's Photo Tanker579 May 07 2012

View PostSabertoothpython, on May 07 2012 - 12:06, said:

Why cant a tank destroyer have a tank gun? Fixed gun emplacments can. Ships can.

Someone please tell me
A tank destroyer can't have a tank gun becuase it's a Tank Destroyer.Not a tank. Duh :D
Quote

Tanker579's Photo Tanker579 May 07 2012

a tank destroyer cant have a tank gun because it's a Tank Destroyer. Duh :D
Quote

Sabertoothpython's Photo Sabertoothpython May 07 2012

View PostTanker579, on May 07 2012 - 12:28, said:

a tank destroyer cant have a tank gun because it's a Tank Destroyer. Duh :D

Thats just a name. Anyway, can the gun on a tank not destroy another tank?

Thus, it is also a tank destroyer
Quote

God_Of_Death_EX's Photo God_Of_Death_EX May 07 2012

btw according to a removed russian tankopeida page
the gun will be released in "Ausfuhrung A" version
that means even u buy this tank, u cannot unlock the regular PaK / KwK 43 L/71
also the radio will be FuG7A with 710m signal range, and not compatible with the regular FuG7
Edited by God_Of_Death_EX, May 07 2012 - 12:38.
Quote

SHISHKABOB's Photo SHISHKABOB May 07 2012

View PostSabertoothpython, on May 07 2012 - 12:34, said:

Thats just a name. Anyway, can the gun on a tank not destroy another tank?

Thus, it is also a tank destroyer

the military loves proper designations

tank destroyers get anti-tank weapons

tanks get tank guns

there's a difference, but it's not very obvious in this game, since all we do in this game is fight other tanks and SPGs
Quote

Lert's Photo Lert May 07 2012

The difference is in the fact that PaK guns in this game seem to have better accuracy, aim time and ROF than KwK guns. That's all. I'm sure the stats of the gun won't change based on what the devs call it but be based completely on gameplay balance, but, however minor, it's still a mistake: the gun should be labeled PaK rather than KwK.
Quote

FujiTnak's Photo FujiTnak May 07 2012

View PostGod_Of_Death_EX, on May 07 2012 - 11:53, said:

The abbrv. KwK refers to KampfwagenKanone
Meaning Tank Gun (according to Google Translate)
And is for turreted tanks only
This is the historical gun for the Tiger II

The gun on the Premium JgT should be 8.8cm PaK 43 L/7
The abbrv. PaK refers to  Panzerbwehrkanone
Meaning Anti Tank Gun (according to Google translate)
PaKs should be mounted on TDs instead of the KwKs
This is the historical gun for the JagdPanther

Hope the DEVs can correct this

Yup, went back and looked. The JagdPanther uses that exact cannon, and its labelled PaK 43. It will most likely be fixed. :Smile_honoring:
Quote

God_Of_Death_EX's Photo God_Of_Death_EX May 07 2012

and a -1 for me for pointing out mistake?
Quote

FujiTnak's Photo FujiTnak May 07 2012

View PostGod_Of_Death_EX, on May 07 2012 - 12:59, said:

and a -1 for me for pointing out mistake?

No worries, gave you +1 to fix someone elses ignorance. Nice for catching that error B)
Quote

frostys's Photo frostys May 07 2012

View PostGod_Of_Death_EX, on May 07 2012 - 12:38, said:

btw according to a removed russian tankopeida page
the gun will be released in "Ausfuhrung A" version
that means even u buy this tank, u cannot unlock the regular PaK / KwK 43 L/71
also the radio will be FuG7A with 710m signal range, and not compatible with the regular FuG7

And that change what? Should all tank be forced to use the same radio set now? My soviet radio works just fine with american radios and german radios so a different set will not make any difference. For all I know, they put a FuG7A on it so people cannot get the FuG7 researched for "free" by buying the new TD. I understand wanting to correct the misstake on the PaK gun but the radio definately has a reason to be different in game.
Quote

God_Of_Death_EX's Photo God_Of_Death_EX May 07 2012

View Postfrostys, on May 07 2012 - 13:05, said:

And that change what? Should all tank be forced to use the same radio set now? My soviet radio works just fine with american radios and german radios so a different set will not make any difference. For all I know, they put a FuG7A on it so people cannot get the FuG7 researched for "free" by buying the new TD. I understand wanting to correct the misstake on the PaK gun but the radio definately has a reason to be different in game.

im just telling some facts
not demanding the DEVs to change them
Quote

Tishr's Photo Tishr May 07 2012

I'd wait and see when the patch goes live bets are the translator just got in a hurry and didn't properly double cheak their work.
Quote

Monadnock's Photo Monadnock May 07 2012

View PostGod_Of_Death_EX, on May 07 2012 - 12:59, said:

and a -1 for me for pointing out mistake?

Fixed.  Good catch.
Quote

God_Of_Death_EX's Photo God_Of_Death_EX May 07 2012

View PostFujiTnak, on May 07 2012 - 13:01, said:

No worries, gave you +1 to fix someone elses ignorance. Nice for catching that error B)

View PostMonadnock, on May 07 2012 - 14:14, said:

Fixed.  Good catch.

thanks for appreciation, and neutralization of the neg
Quote

KilljoyCutter's Photo KilljoyCutter May 07 2012

Of course, in real life, German tanks and TDs often mounted the same guns, with the difference being just in the name and maybe the mount.

http://en.wikipedia....iki/KwK_43_L/71
Quote
Get the IPS Communities App for iPhone now!